Laura Zembrodt
Older red-brick home with dormer windows, limestone entry steps, and a broad autumn lawn beneath a maple tree.

The Old Kyles Lane Frisch's Is Becoming a Chop House Built Around Fort Wright's Gourmet Strip Past

Part of Fort Wright's name history starts with a restaurant. The oldest of the four cities that merged to form it was Lookout Heights, incorporated in 1937 and named for the hill where the Lookout House nightclub stood. The city's own history calls the Lookout House "a cornerstone of the old Dixie Highway 'Gourmet Strip'," offering fine dining, Las Vegas-style entertainment and gambling. The Lookout Corporate Center now stands on that spot.

That's how most of the strip went. The supper clubs and taverns that once lined Dixie Highway became offices or event spaces, burned down, or were replaced. The corner of Kyles Lane is going the other way. The Frisch's that sat there for years moved to a new spot nearby without closing, and the building it left is being rebuilt as a sit-down restaurant whose owners are openly naming the Gourmet Strip as their model. Fort Wright keeps its Frisch's on Orphanage Road and gains a 160-seat chop house on Kyles Lane.

The Frisch's Moved Down the Road and Took Its Crew

The Kyles Lane Frisch's didn't close. It reopened in August at 494 Orphanage Road, and LINK nky reported that the entire Kyles Lane team would transfer to the new restaurant. The new location used to be a Frisch's too. It sat empty for a long time and was remodeled back into one. Its local owner, Cheryl White, worked for Frisch's for more than 30 years.

The move was planned months ahead. In March, WCPO reporting carried by LINK nky described a rendering on display inside the Kyles Lane restaurant. It showed the location moving to a Greer-owned property on Madison Pike at Orphanage Road, under a redesigned look the company calls the "3L Frisch's." The name comes from Madison Pike, Kentucky Route 17, which in the early 20th century connected the horse racing cities of Louisville, Lexington and Latonia. The new design plays down the Big Boy logo and sets the Frisch's name in a different typeface.

The same report noted that the Kyles Lane building had changed hands the previous September, when Guardian Savings Bank sold the land and building to 20 Kyles Lane LLC. The report said it wasn't clear whether the ownership change played a part in the move.

This matters because of what happened to Frisch's across the region. The chain closed 65 locations in 2024. Fort Wright kept its Frisch's and got its building back for a new tenant.

What the Carmelo's Team Plans for 20 Kyles Lane

The new tenant comes from Billy Grise and Mitch Arens, co-owners of Carmelo's on Madison Avenue in Covington. They opened Carmelo's in November 2024, and in January USA Today readers voted it the No. 2 best new restaurant in the United States. Both restaurants operate under Something Underground Hospitality, the group the two men founded, according to the NKyTribune. The paper reported in early October that the Fort Wright restaurant is planned to open this winter.

Here's what the owners have described so far:

  • Format: an American chop house, which is a little different from a steakhouse. LINK nky explained that the term started in Britain in 1690 and meant casual places serving all kinds of meat, not just steak, where men stopped for a quick meal after work.
  • Size: 160 seats plus an outdoor patio.
  • Design: Grise and Arens are working on the name and design, which will draw on the history of Dixie Highway and the stretch through Fort Wright once known as the Gourmet Strip.
  • Food: Arens, the chef, described it to LINK nky as "comfort food you recognize before you taste it."

Grise told LINK nky that the team is "channeling old-school hospitality in a historic building, and giving the people of Fort Wright a place to escape to again." The word "again" points back to the strip. Arens said in the same piece that he grew up in a large Northern Kentucky family, where "dinner was a table full of food and a room filled with everyone I love."

From an architect's point of view, this is a real reuse project. A quick-service restaurant built around counter traffic is being reworked into a 160-seat dining room with a patio. A conversion like that changes how the building meets the street and how people move through it once they're inside.

The Strip the New Restaurant Is Borrowing From

The Gourmet Strip had more than one landmark. NKU historian Paul Tenkotte, writing in the NKyTribune, counted more than a dozen places along the route, including Marshall's, the Golden Goose, Town and Country, the Lookout House, Oelsner's Colonial Tavern, Foltz's Hofbrau Haus, the Hearthstone, the Greyhound Grill and Retschulte's Five Mile House. The Park Hills Civic Association dates the commercial boom on Dixie Highway to the 1930s and adds Nick Behle's Old Lamp Lighter, the White Horse, Chappie's Tavern and Blue Star.

Here's what became of a few of those sites:

Gourmet Strip name What happened What's there now
Lookout House, Fort Wright Grew from an 1880s tavern into a dining, entertainment and gambling club Lookout Corporate Center
White Horse, 1501 Dixie Highway Opened in 1936 as the first restaurant heading south from Covington; destroyed by fire in January 1972 The later Edgewood location closed in 1978
Blue Star, Park Hills Opened in 1936; renamed Town and Country in 1950 The Gardens of Park Hills, per NKY Views
Golden Goose, Park Hills Later became Szechuan Garden Szechuan Garden is shuttered; the site has a redevelopment proposal
Five Mile House, Lakeside Park 19th-century toll stop, then a Retschulte family restaurant Barleycorn's

In Tenkotte's account, the White Horse moved to Edgewood after the fire instead of rebuilding at 1501 Dixie Highway, and that location closed in 1978.

Where the Old Route Still Serves Dinner

A few strip names still serve dinner just outside Fort Wright's limits. The Greyhound Grill, on Tenkotte's list, continues as Greyhound Tavern at 2500 Dixie Highway in Fort Mitchell, where its website lists current hours and takes reservations. Farther south in Lakeside Park, Barleycorn's traces its site back to the Five Mile House. The Retschulte family bought that toll stop in 1910, and Barleycorn's started there in 1984.

In both cases, the restaurant tradition lasted where a restaurant kept the address. The Lookout House site, the one that gave Lookout Heights its name, changed use completely.

What the Kyles Lane Corner Looks Like This Winter

The Frisch's moved with its full staff to Madison Pike and Orphanage Road under the 3L name. The building it left at 20 Kyles Lane is planned to reopen this winter as a 160-seat chop house with a patio, designed to recall the stretch that once drew people to Dixie Highway for dinner.

  1. 494 Orphanage Road: the relocated Frisch's, locally owned by Cheryl White, with the former Kyles Lane team.
  2. 20 Kyles Lane: the Something Underground Hospitality chop house from Billy Grise and Mitch Arens, planned for this winter.
  3. 2500 Dixie Highway, Fort Mitchell: Greyhound Tavern, the strip's Greyhound Grill name still serving.
  4. Lakeside Park: Barleycorn's, on the old Five Mile House site.

The Lookout House, which gave Lookout Heights its name, is now the site of a corporate center, and the corner of Kyles Lane is being rebuilt to serve dinner in the strip's style.

If you live near Dixie Highway and want to know how a building like 20 Kyles Lane gets reworked for a new use, or what that kind of change means for the streets around your home, I'm happy to walk through it with you. With my architecture background, it's my favorite kind of question. Laura Zembrodt can help you look at the structure and the street together. Schedule a Consultation.

Work With Laura

Contact Laura today to assist you with selling or buying your next home. She will work with you through every step. She understands the real estate process and believes in educating clients when selling or buying a home.

Follow Me on Instagram